Buster v. Bargain--Gold Medal Winner and Blue Ribbon Worthy

I have been really into statement necklaces as of late (as you can tell from the recent posts), and the Kate Spade piece above was sent to me by M.  While the colors are not the same, the beauty of each necklace is apparent--whether it is Kate Spade's version in a vibrant turquoise shade of blue, or JcPenney's Blue and Gold Medallion Necklace in a rich and regal shade of royal blue.  Which do you like better??  I love them both!!